I saw the other day that Kordia had a big party to release their new radio service. They sent out heaps of fancy invites and touted it as the next best thing. The only problem with all this hype is that the system isn’t new and it’s bollocks to boot.
I have a real problem with proprietary systems and KorKor…god doesn’t that just sound like the call of a dying crow…..is no exception. It is exclusively Motorola equipment and it costs an absolute fortune when compared with other more open trunked Radio systems. Further it isn’t as though Trunked Radio is something new and fantastic, especially Tetra based trunked radio systems.
Kordia describes, rather wankily, KorKor on their website as;
“Superior quality, world-class features and usability, reliability, and unbeatable service. That’s what you can expect from KorKor™ in the field. “
Unfortunately for them their bullshit cannot be matched with any sort of facts. In fact quite the contrary where there is actually ample evidence to suggest that Kordia has once again pillaged the tax-payer to implement a system that no-one needs and no-one wants. You see Tetra systems are the radio equivalent of CDMA compared to GSM in the cellular world. Few countries have it, handsets are expensive, and it doesn’t bloody work.
In the UK a similar system was implemented for the Emergency services and as reviewed in a damning report that blamed deaths on the failure of this radio system that KorKor is based upon.
There is even a website specifically to watch and warn about Tetra-based systems. I expect Kordia will be featuring on their pages in short order.
There are numerous articles about the failure of Tetra based systems, particularly in the UK.
Ever bought a new car, only to find…? (description of the UK system comparing it to buying a new car)
Scottish Police Federation reservations about Airwave
Emergency services face network delays 17 November 2004
Edinburgh: £2.9bn police radio system ‘faulty’
Questions remain over the future of Airwave 30 June 2004
Mail on Sunday, 20 June 2004: £2bn police radio ‘out of date already’
The Times, 17 June 2004: ‘£2.9bn police radio link ineffective’
Computing Magazine, 17 June 2004: ‘Concerns grow over Airwave emergency services radio’
Computing Magazine, 16 June 2004: ‘Concerns grow over police radio system’
Computer Weekly, 27 April 2004: The Met future-proofs with Tetra handsets (ie, they buy handsets that the network cannot provide for!)
And there’s more, when you’ve read this page
Got all that…..the UK spent over £2.9bn on a radio system that doesn’t work and in 2004 was listed as out of date already. Quite a different picture from what Kordia paints isn’t it?
In the Netherlands a similar system was introduced and is yet to be fully operational. The C2000 Tetra Network is in the area of Amsterdam is in a strict pilot phase. Due to multipath interferences, software instability, hieratic black-out on the network varying from 40 minutes to 8 hours, the TETRA radios are not used in nominal mode. The old legacy system is remaining the primary radio network.
It was reported that Police Officers refused to use the radio because of health concerns. The emergency services (Fire Brigades and Ambulances did some trials but are not using it for mission critical operations).
Motorola recently extended the roll-out of some more base stations, but the all network does not yet cover the Netherlands. Motorola offered to implement a new software release but the Dutch Government refused to pay.
This all sounds positively wonderful for Kordia doesn’t it. The red ink will continue to flow in their books but the board won’t care they have the long suffering taxpayer to pick up the bill.
I think it is time that the Minister responsible cast a wary eye acros the activities and predatory practises of Kordia and started to hold the board and senior management to account.
February 25th, 2009 at 5:14 pm
Guys if an MP fronts here, please be civil and not just go off topic with old stuff.
And for what it is worth I agree National MPs should be on as often as they are invited.