What a ridiculous judgment

The Broadcasting Standards Authority has found that Michael Laws;

…unfairly represented Mr Broughton’s views.

Mr Broughton had said that “Pakeha continue to allow [smoking] in the country and make profits from it’, but Laws told his listeners that Mr Broughton believed, and told his clients, that smoking is a “Pakeha plot to kill Maori’, an assertion he made several times during the course of his programme.

“The authority is firm in its view that such blatant misrepresentation cannot be regarded as `fair comment’, as argued by the broadcaster,” the decision said.

The authority considered whether upholding the complaint would infringe on the broadcaster’s freedom of expression, but decided its decision would remind broadcasters to ensure they dealt with people referred to in a programme fairly.

With my submission to the Maori Affairs Select Committee on Maori smoking highlights the culture of the Maori anti-smoking lobby. I hope to present a full submission to the Select Committee in person and table my evidence of Shane Kawaneta Bradbrook’s epic failure along with other Maori anti-smoking campaigners.

Mr Broughton is on my list of people who are part of a nasty spiteful list of anti-smoking adherents discovered via the OIA.

Tagged:
  • http://keepingstock.blogspot.com/ Inventory2

    Broadcasting Standards – surely, that’s an oxymoron!

  • giblet

    It reminds me of the Pacific Islanders who blame their obesity on New Zealand’s history of shipping tins of corned beef to the Islands.

    Anyone who has been at Auckland airport when the weekly flight for Niue leaves would be astounded at the quantity of takeaway food that is sent over. For the Airport KFC and McDonald’s stores, it is their biggest order.

  • MT_Tinman

    Time for an end to the absurdity that is the BSA.

    Let the halfwits go back to writing letters to The Editor.

  • baxter

    Surely that none of the members would hold inverted racist views, the members, Joanne MORRIs appointed 2003 also member Waitangi Tribunal, Tapu MISA (nuff said) Mary SHANAHAN a lawyer whose husband is from Ngati Toa, and Paul France formerly Stateowned TV News bigwig.

  • Mad Cow

    If the Maori Party want to play Nanny State then how about they first start by banning all those enrolled on the Maori role from smoking and then review how successful the policy was after the next election.

  • spectator

    Hey Giblet, it reminds me of the rednecks who blame their privilege on Maori and Pacific Island stupidity and lazyness. Grow up! The judgement was about Laws making up stories about how Broughton carried out his work. Nothing more, nothing less. Laws is an ass looking for a headline wherever he can get one, Broughton was just a foolish reply and got burned by an ass.