Who's tougher, Gillard or Tolley?

http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/give-good-teachers-a-gold-star-and-put-the-bad-ones-out-to-pasture-20100203-ndfa.html

One is an industrial relations lawyer and a socialist youth leader, and the other isnt. They are both fighting the same good fight, a fight that has been fought and won by the politicians in other nations, like the US and the UK. Both are taking on what Miranda Devine calls “the self-interested screaming of neanderthal teachers’ unions”

Miranda reckons:

The war against teachers’ unions is on – only this time it is not from their traditional conservative enemies, who have proved spectacularly unsuccessful over the past decade in breaking union control of education.

A new resolve from the unions’ old allies and enablers, the Australian Labor Party, and in the US the Democrats, unable any longer to ignore the disastrous effect of progressive policies of the past 40 years, looks like finally breaking their destructive dominance.

Obviously the teachers union are going to keep whinging about how an elected government with a mandate from the electorate has no right to impose policy on the teachers union because teachers are holier than thou. Teachers unions would be best dealt with a policy of Caedite eos. Novit enim Dominus qui sunt eius. Unfortunately the law is quite strict on this kind of thing though.

  • The Gantt Guy

    Gillard, definitely. She's a leftard socialist through & through. Her employment relations portfolio is clear evidence of this. But she is taking on the teachers' union over this because of overwhelming electoral support for national standards. The myschool website is sensational. An actual ability to compare schools, so I can decide where to send my daughter to primary school next year. That's not to say the teachers union has rolled over,of course. There was an article in today's Herald Sun about teachers being instructed to "teach to the test".

    Bring it on Tolley!!!

    • Sinner

      myschool is frankly reason enough for anyone with school age kids to head across the Tassman.

  • becn

    I've read the standards. I would be quite happy if my child's teacher "taught to the test". Providing it's not fraud by making him memorize the test book for literacy, if he can pass those tests then he's developed some reading skills.

    Bring on the standards

  • Michael

    People didn't think Margaret Thatcher would be tough enough to take on the Coalminers Union. Afterwards, they called her the Iron Lady. Maybe you should get a new nickname for Anne Tolley ready – Anne "Maggie" Tolley.

    • Sinner

      Let's call Tolley an iron lady after the cops have baton-charged, tasered, and waterblasted horders of protesting teachers, lefties, unionists, and labourists

      Frankly when the Hikoi the teachers are talking about comes into Wellington, I'd meet it with the AOS and gun the lot of them down. The go to the country and get 60% or so – and the change the constitution act so that Labour, the Greens or any other lefties can never get government again

      NZEI et Labourum delenda est

  • http://www.nightcitytrader.blogspot.com Elijah Lineberry

    Gillard is extremely tough and very ruthless; from what I gather she is actually quite 'menacing' in person (unless you are one of her constituents and then she is very charming! hahaha!) and even Rudd is wary of her.

    Tolley is a bit of a wet fish by comparison.

    • Sinner

      Tolley hasn't begun to fight yet. Wait and see: she'll surprise you!

  • Theresaj

    Tolley isn't capable of holding a discussion. She speaks in pre rehearsed sound bites. Hardly a good look for a Minister of Education.

    • Sinnetr

      lefty fuckwit. Excellent skills for dealing with unionists, leftist, and teacher unions.

      I mean: how hard it it so say: your schools have all been sold of to infratil

      Go on – try it for yourself! See! I'm sure Tolley can manage it.

  • thor42

    I think Gillard wins the toughness test.
    ***Good on her!*** FINALLY, after countless decades, there is someone who is willing to stand up to the teacher unions. ABOUT TIME! I'm only disappointed that she's not *our* Education Minister.

  • ???

    No Offense but Tolley is full of crap. If you actually bothered to check you would know that teachers have been teaching to national standards for years. The only reason national government wants to do this is because as schools we have been instructed not to test esol or special needs so there will be no tail end low learners in the school and bam! the results look great. If they focused more on helping students with disabilities in classes then instead of fobbing them off all the time then maybe that would be better.