The troughing of Labour

“Cut and Run” Phil Goff is unrepentant over nicking more than $30,000 of taxpayers money in order to fund his non-message bus tour. A minister in National resigned over inappropriate spending of just $70.00 showing far more integrity than “Cut and Run” Phil Goff. His sense of entitlement to dip into taxpayer funds to run his campaigns is repulsive

"Cut and "Run Goff with his snout in the troughLabour’s “Axe the Tax” bus trip protesting GST increases is costing the taxpayer about $30,000 – but Labour leader Phil Goff has defended it as the cheapest way to get around the country on an issue that affects everybody.

The Labour Party has chartered the bus for a fortnight-long nationwide trip protesting against the Government’s proposal to increase GST to 15 per cent, with compensatory tax cuts that Labour claims will advantage high-income earners.

The bus features a red “skin” with Axe the Tax signage and Labour logos.

A spokesman for Mr Goff said the costs were expected to be about $30,000, including for the bus charter, the signage and other material such as signs and balloons.

He is a trougher extraordinaire. He is supping along with his party at the biggest trough there is, parliamentary funding. We can only trust “Cut and Run” Phil Goff for the figures too because all of the funding that he has availed himself of has been from a post of taxpayers gold beyond the reach of the Official Information Act. We have to trust a man known less for his honesty and more for his spinelessness, that the figures are accurate.

Not only that “Cut and Run” Goff suggests basically that if we don’t like the bus, well he could always have used his minsterial limousine.

The bus was the cheapest way to get around the country and to places that were not on main transport routes.

It would cost significantly more for him to use Crown cars to travel around in and for other MPs to use individual forms of transport. The signage was attention-grabbing and ensured people knew exactly what the MPs were there to talk about.

What a fuckwit! Not only he lies again. The bus may be attention seeking, at least he is honest about for a man desperately seeking relevance but to say that the trip ensured people knew exactly what they ere talking about is a straight out lie. They are most certainly not talking about Axing GST completely and it is they are also NOT talking about dropping GST, and most certainly they won’t be talking about removing the increase in GST should the unlikely occur and they win office at the next election, so it begs the obvious question. Just what are they talking about?

Well I can tell you that those figures are highly suspect. For a start to wrap a bus that big with a full wrap, which is what they have done would probably come in at more than $10,000. That is a third of his $30,000. The rental of the bus would presumably includes a driver because I doubt any Labour MP has the necessary Class 2 licence and P endorsement to drive the bus. Let’s assume that a driver is supplied and he drives the maximum legal hours he can including all break required by law and rest stops of 12 hours per day. Let’s also be generous and say that the driver is paid at the top end of usual bus driver rates at $16p/h. The wages bill alone for the driver is $2688.00, there would also need to be accommodation costs in there, so that adds another $1170 for the two weeks. Labour would never spring for a nice motel for the driver, they would save those rooms for themselves. We are now almost at half of the cost of “Cut and Run” Phil Goff’s $30,000.

We still not have seen how much the daily charter is, the RUC, and the diesel fuel. In a bus like that the fuels costs would be about $150 per day, but that may be light. Still at $150 per day that is the not inconsquential sum of $2100. Now we are definately over halfway on the costs.

I think it is high time that “Cut and Run” Phil Goff produced the receipts to justify his figure of $30,000. I would suggest he will refuse out right given his taking umbrage at the suggestion he is troughing at our expense. To refuse would merely confirm my hypothesis that he is obfuscating on the costs.

The Speaker too needs to start thinking very seriously about the opening up of parliamentary services to greater scrutiny by removing the restriction preventing the OIA being used to prevent the public who pay for this silliness from seeing just how much troughing is going on. If he doesn’t it can only be a matter of time before there is a whistle-blower that dumps heaps of info in the hands of a blogger.

  • petal

    As hinted at by DPF in a similar post, it would be interesting to track, trace and report on the amount of airline flights by Labour MPs and staff in and out to where the bus happens to be at the time, and any incidental spending on town hall meetings, lunches etc. Labour have a curious lack of sense as to what is the right thing to do – they genuinely seem to act like a union protesting instead of an opposition party.

  • garry

    I dont think anyone whatever their political hue, could ever condone the spending on this bus – the bus is clearly a party political broadcast on wheels – with a group of people singing fireside songs like “Kumbaya” while they travel at public expense.

    I dont understand how an intelligent educated guy like Goff could be so stupid – given the issues that have been raised time and time again over corrupt behaviour like this. Dont they see that the public has clearly had enough of it. The same people who will talk tough about closing tax loopholes – or “3 strikes” demonstrate at their level – that they believe if you can get away with it .. do it. At least thats my uninformed opinion.

    Even ACT got involved – and they were meant to hold the moral high ground. For me, Rodney Hides apology for being caught wont wash away what he did – ever. They all only said sorry for being caught. In my book thats just remorse – not genuine sorrow. They may argue they work within the rules – when they are caught with their sticky fingers in the cookie jar it becomes very obvious by body language they knew all along it was morally wrong.

    Bill English – a man who probably has more money than a bull can pass through its alimentary canal … getting a nice little payoff on his privately owned property for instance.

    If it was you or I or our kids – we would all be in court so quick our feet wouldnt touch the ground.

    Cheers
    G

  • http://keepingstock.blogspot.com/ Inventory2

    Phil ought to be more careful as to how the bus is driven. I’m sure they didn’t realise that it was a blogger who doesn’t like Labour who couldn’t catch up with the bus this morning, even though the blogger was going faster than the speed limit.

    I can only guess that Chris Carter, The Shadow Minsiter for Own Goals was aboard in Wanganui this morning!!!

    http://keepingstock.blogspot.com/2010/03/faster-than-speeding-tax-bus.html

  • mediatart

    How silly . The funding is for party political purposes. Thats the whole idea.

    No different than Keys big spend of $250,000 for letters to primary school parents .

    Lets hope the ‘bus’ gets lots of photo ops . Lets hope Mps fly in and out wherever.

    Its getting more mileage than dropkick Tolley who is hiding in the backrooms for her nationwide National standards tour

  • Axeman

    The Goof was out and about in Taranaki yesterday – but the crowds weren’t.
    http://www.stuff.co.nz/taranaki-daily-news/news/3406829/Campaign-about-re-engaging-voters

  • Malcolm Jackson

    Not very PC of the Taranaki Daily News to call Goof’s followers “party heavyweights Annette King and Trevor Mallard”. Have they been following them to Macca’s???? :)

  • Bill Nonames

    John Boscawen says if Labour is so concerned that an increase in tax will hurt low income families – as demonstrated by Labour’s ‘axe the tax bus’ against a 2.5 percent increase in GST – then why isn’t Phil Goff prepared to stand against the ETS tax and campaign for it to be scrapped.

    Low income families will be hit hard when the ETS tax causes electricity and petrol prices to rise by 5 percent on July 1 this year.

    However, unlike National’s proposed increase in GST, there will be no compensation to low income earners for this new ETS tax.

    Not only will the new ETS tax increase the price of electricity and petrol, but it will see the costs of all goods rise as businesses raise their prices to cover the extra costs.

    It was Labour that first introduced this new tax, and if National had not amended it, on Jan 1 this year all kiwi families would have been facing a 10 percent increase in their power bills.

    It seems very hypocritical that Labour was happy to see a tax of 10 percent introduced on electricity, but are now fighting against a 2.5 percent increase in GST.

    The ETS tax will put pressure on many low income families already struggling to pay their bills. If Goff really cares about low income families then this is the tax that Labour should be fighting to axe.

    You onto it John.

  • bigkev

    oh oh the bikies are comin to town

    Next week, David Cunliffe and Annette King will take over for some of the South Island leg while Mr Goff and Rick Barker visit Northland on their motorbikes. They will be joined by local MPs while there.

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/politics/news/article.cfm?c_id=280&objectid=10629952

    • http://whaleoil.gotcha.co.nz Whaleoil

      Big kev, there aren’t any Labour MPs north of Mt Albert, not a single one, I guess Silent P and Cut & Run will be themselves.

  • jabba

    poor Phil .. I can only assume Little is beavering away trying to make him go missing without too much blood.