On the Nation today Phil Goff effectively conceded the next election.
He won’t categorically agree to reverse any GST increase despite spending thousands campaigning around the country on our ticket and he wants to reverse any tax cuts implemented by National. Worse that he will work with Winston Raymond Peters, 65, unemployed of St Mary’s Bay.
DUNCAN: Would you also cut the GST increase which is coming in the May Budget, you’ve campaigned on it for the last few months, more than 15%, can you give us a direct answer to that?
PHIL: Yeah well I’ve given the direct answer and it said that the honest answer is we can’t tell at this stage whether we can do that, we’ve gotta sum up what the situation is at the time, we’re going to under promise and over deliver, not the other way around.
DUNCAN: Okay, well that’s a no as far as I’m concerned.
PHIL: No no, it’s that we’re keeping our options open, but we’re not making promises that we don’t think that we can carry out or don’t know yet.
DUNCAN: Ten years ago when Labour came to office you campaigned on that top rate of tax 39 cents, it’s now 38, it’s not secret that John Key and the National government are going to drop that to 33 in the next budget. Would you go into the next election campaigning for a return to that top rate?
PHIL: What we’d go in to the next election about is using that two billion dollars, most of which will go to the very top income earners, to help middle income and low income earners in New Zealand, it shouldn’t just go to the few the top 7%, middle income earners are finding it pretty tough, they miss out both ways, low income earners are struggling to make ends meet, they’re the people that are the priorities.
DUNCAN: Can I get a specific answer to that question?
PHIL: Yeah, it will be about making sure that the tax cuts when we get in are turned around to be fair to middle and lower income earners, and not just to reward the privileged few.
National will be ecstatic about this. Labour can’t be believed with their Axe the Tax campaign and they will put taxes up. Those are the simple sound bites that no matter how Phil Goff and Labour spins it will be what their policy is all about. Increasing taxes.
DUNCAN: Philosophically Labour has always agreed with that top rate of tax targeting those people just like Michael Cullen did when he came to office in 1999, you still haven’t given me and the viewers a direct answer about whether Labour would have a top rate of tax.
PHIL: Oh look 38 cents in the dollar is not a high top tax rate by international standards. In Australia it’s 45, in the United Kingdom it’s 50, in Scandinavia it’s 60. We’re comfortable with 38, if there’s gonna be tax cuts they should go to the middle and lower income earners, not simply the privileged elite. That’s a very clear answer.
DUNCAN: Just to make it even clearer would you restore it back to 38?
PHIL : Oh 38 I’m very comfortable with, I see no reason to cut the top tax rate below that, in preference to helping middle and lower income earners.
So what we can now tell is that Phil Goff won’t let taxes go below 38 cents and also thinks that 38 cents is very low. He lies by omission by concentrating on just tax rates without addressing thresholds and whilst Australia a top rate of 45 cents it has much, much higher thresholds.
PHIL:Â There are things that I disagree with that they do, some of their policy I think are bad, some of their other policy ideas are akin to ours, if we have to we’ll work with the Greens, we’ll work with the Maori Party, we’d work with New Zealand First if it came back, but it would be around a programme that we think is for New Zealanders and what New Zealanders need.
Good. So now the voters know that a vote for Labour is a vote for Winston Peters. The best laugh is last though.
DUNCAN: I just want one thing, this week you had that survey, you talked about funky, futuristic, cool.
PHIL: I didn’t talk about those things.
DUNCAN:Well your party is, how would you describe yourself in one word?
PHIL: In one word, I’m interested in a better New Zealand, that’s why I’m in politics.
Phil Goff can’t even count. Can a man who doesn’t know what one word means be trusted to run the countries finances. He uses 11 words when asked for one!
At least we know that voting for a Phil Goff led Labour party will mean something now. It will mean higher taxes, GST remaining at 15%, Winston Peters back in a ministerial limousine.