September 2010

Labour Finance Minister on GST

4 August 2004 from Hansard

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: I am aware of many countries that have appallingly inefficient GST systems where they exempt various articles, where they have differential rates, and where one has to differentiate between food taken away from a place and food consumed within a place. Thank goodness we have not followed those very bad policies. I am certainly aware in New Zealand of GST being levied on top of other taxes. Every time the member fills up his petrol tank he is doing precisely that.

Gordon Copeland: Can he confirm that during the last decade the then Government had an opportunity to revisit the question of GST on rates, but decided to retain the status quo, and can he confirm that the Minister who made that decision was the Rt Hon Winston Peters when he was Treasurer in 1997?

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: I will take the member’s word for that and congratulate the right honourable gentleman on his wise decision.

Rt Hon Winston Peters: Will the Minister confirm that when I left the office of Treasurer—and a very sad day it was for this country—I instructed Treasury to continue its research on the core element of rates on which one could properly say that it is a tax on a tax, and not all rates in the way that the loose United Party is looking at this issue?

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: I thank the member for that advice, but that rather reduces my congratulations to him, because that would muddy up the GST system very substantially.

Just remind me again because I seem to have forgotten, but weren’t Phil Goff and David Cunliffe part of cabinet under the Helen Clark led government that didn’t contemplate the removal of GST from fresh fruit and vegetable for 9 years because it “would muddy up the GST system very substantially”.

Endorsements and such

We are into the final two weeks of the election campaign and there are endorsements and dis-endorsements going on.

Matt McCarten has given me a wild card endorsement;

If you want adventure on the new Council, my personal favourite is Cam Slater, the blog editor of WhaleOil. Slater is a right winger but if Williams and Slater are elected then at least the new Council will be interesting.

McCarten says that Williams is “progressive” which is actually a pinko. So voters in Albany are under no illusions that Andrew Williams is actually a pinko and that is why him and Len Brown are so matey on the election trail. Len Brown’s spin weasel, Conor Roberts, said to me on Friday that “there is no deal, Andrew Williams has to be elected first”. Not an emphatic denial, and nice weasel words but a deal has been done and they know that we know.

Metro aren’t so kind about the Clown from Campbell’s Bay nor about his enabler Julia Parfitt.

They recommend John Kirikiri from Rodnet. John is a straight shooter and the two of us have had a whole heap of fun at public meetings. I’d vote for him.

Meanwhile right on cue from all his bad press the last few days the Mad Mayor has again been spraying around the press releases. The paranoia of the man shows that he clearly has the results of the same poll I’ve got hold of and knows he is screwed and so is flailing around trying to blame everyone under the sun for his demise.

One of his mad rambling emails says;

“his covert political activities aimed at me which were linked to Cameron Slater and other political opponents of mine.”

Andrew Williams clearly hasn’t heard of the Bill of Rights Act 1990. In particular Articles 13, 14 and 17. But the paranoia is astounding….”covert political activities“!

Another press release says;

“The most alarming involved questionable ethics of Councillor Chris Darby, the leader of Shore Voice, who I am informed took advantage of a special needs couple to secure one of Shore Voice’s billboards sites. The complaint I received stated that the confused couple were given promises of having their kerb fixed in front of their house by Chris Darby, a promise he may not make during the three month election period as it can be construed as “treating”. I am advised that the special needs couple were also very  concerned that a Shore Voice billboard was put on their front lawn as they were not fully sure of why. in their somewhat confused special needs state.”

Yes that is verbatim. And he sent that one at 11am, so clearly well oiled before lunchtime. It doesn’t get any better though, the press release, again sent out under the title of Mayoral New Release, shows his utter paranoia and abrogation of democratic principles.

“These included aiding and abetting an Albany Ward candidate Cameron Slater (of Whaleoil notoriety) with material to attack me as Mayor and activities affecting other councillors.”

Ohhhh, aiding and abetting…sounds like criminals…oh wait I am! Glad he has noted my notoriety. But I’ve left the best rant till last.

“These two individuals have no scruples and will stoop to anything, and the public need to be aware of this.”

Oh yes Andrew we all know now, you have sprayed this all over the place. Hopefully the time of the Father Jack of Auckland politics is nearly over. Andrew Williams is definitely on a bender and showing up his petty bullyboy attitude loud and clear. He clearly has a Napolean complex, his Waterloo isn’t far off.

Rudman bleating about his theatre again

Two weeks from election day and cue Brian Rudman bleating about a theatre.

My challenge to the mayoral candidates a couple of weeks back, to embrace Auckland’s role as cultural capital of the country, had a predictable enough response. Total ignore from Auckland mayoral front-runners Len Brown and John Banks, and squawks of outrage from Wellington.

Blah, blah, blah…Rudman is like a stuck record on “culture” in particular his pet liberal elite project, a theatre. Is it any wonder that everyone now ignores his bleating.

Both Mr Banks and Mr Brown list their desire to save the St James Theatre as proof of that.

Desire is all very well, but with the St James Theatre on its last legs during both Mr Banks’ terms as Auckland mayor, what voters deserve before the polls close on Saturday week is something rather more concrete than a vague promise.

If ever there was a symbol of this town’s cavalier approach to its past, it’s the sad, neglected St James. Somehow we did get around to giving it a top level heritage listing according to both the criteria set down by the Historic Places Trust and Auckland City Council. But that done, we just walked away and let it decay.

Only good luck saved it from death by fire, and for several years it has sat abandoned, unsafe for human use, while vague plans for it being entombed inside a residential tower block wax and wane.

As a reminder of the city’s rich theatrical past, it needs to be preserved, but to me there’s an even more important and practical reason for it being resurrected. Auckland needs a 1300-seat lyric theatre to host drama, opera and ballet, shows that currently risk getting lost in the oversized 2200-plus ASB Theatre and Civic auditoriums.

Let me re-iterate one of my campaign promises here. I will oppose the spending of ratepayers money on silly frivolities like Rudman’s theatre projects. If people want the arts and culture then let them pay for them themselves instead of picking the ratepayers pockets.

At the same time a change in rates should allow ratepayers to choose to pay an annual cul tural con­tribution allowing free access to the Opera, Orchestra and Brian Rudman’s Theatre.  If they choose not to pay the cultural contribution then they have to pay full price for access to cultural events. This means we would also charge out of towners the full price instead of Auckland ratepay ers subsi­dising them.

My position on the St James is unequivocal, I don’t care if piss off the liberal arty-farty types, my position is bulldoze the thing and use the valuable land for something useful.

Vote Slater – Albany – Auckland – Keeping the Buggers Honest

Vote Slater - Albany - Auckland - Keeping the Buggers Honest

Vote Slater - Albany - Auckland - Keeping the Buggers Honest

I'm sick of pinko lies

Denis Welch continued the lie that I some how started the “Jim Anderton caused the earthquake” story, these pinko whingers in the media like to think they are above any come back when they trot out their musings unanswered on Red Radio. The Whale bites back.

Chief Executive
Radio New Zealand
PO Box 123
Wellington 6140.

Dear Mr Cavanagh,

I wish to make a complaint under Standard 5 and Standard 6

On his show on Friday 21 September 2010 Denis Welch discusses me and name suppression then segues into a discussion about Jim Anderton.

Dirty trick played on Jim Anderton

He says “This time the dirty trick was played on Jim Anderton, and many people in the media swallowed what appeared to be on Youtube a video showing that Anderton made some crack about that it would take an earthquake for Bob Parker to beat me in the Chch mayoral election, he said this appeared to come from an interview just before the actual earthquake, so no one was saying that he was using the earthquake quite callously in that sense, just that there was a rather bitter irony about the fact he had given this interview just before. Well, in fact, it turns out…not so…”

He then goes on to list a group of commentators which he says were “taken in by it” and had now apologised “quite rightly”.

This suggests that the video on Youtube and the editor of the video was the source of the story. He then discusses “selective editing” and “victim of a right wing blogger” in a seperate case leaving the listener in no doubt that this is the same with the Anderton case.

They then talk about fact checking suggesting that the internet is wild west. He finishes the segment with;

“That really was a dirty trick played on Anderton and I’m very pleased to see that the people who were taken in by it did apologise and make it quite clear that they got the wrong end of the stick or indeed the trick”

In fact it is now Denis Welch that is playing “dirty tricks” by suggesting that the video and the editor of the video was the source of the story and that it was somehow a dirty trick that should be apologised for.

Radio New Zealand’s own Media Watch show acknowledges the correct timeline of events and the source of the story as Felix Marwick from the Radio Network. then NZ Herald, then other media including blogs, Twitter and such, all long before the video appeared.

Mediawatch

It is clear that Denis Welch’s show breached Standard 5 and Standard 6 in terms of fairness and in terms of accuracy.

Denis Welch has actually played his own “dirty trick” with this review of the viral video about Jim Anderton.

It would appropriate for Denis Welch to correct his show, or post a correction online apologizing for giving the impression that the Youtube video and the author of the video was the original source, and that it wasn’t a “dirty trick” but in fact an attempt at satire well after the mainstream media and online media ran with the story propagated by Felix Marwick.

Kris Fa'afoi – National is good for Maori

I think we should all celebrate reporters journalists repeaters telling it the way they see it. Kris Fa’afoi is refreshingly honest, I note he does say “we” a lot when talking about National.

The last line is a cracker…

“The deal that the Maori Party has struck with National is good for Maori.”

I hope he reminds the constituents of Mana this as he campaigns hard for Labour.

Tagged:

That transparency feeling, but with limits

Len Brown is on record as saying he will front up.

“I will always front up. I will give you the straight answers, always with a limit.”

Unfortunately he added that rider, always with a limit. He is also on record with his beliefs about transparency.

“I clearly don’t give a damn about this stuff.”

“It’s critical for me as a point of basic principle as a leader and mayor of the city.

“I sit in this room. I don’t tell anybody I am having an interview with you today. It is between you and me. It is totally confidential.”

He said there was no requirement for him to disclose who he spent council money on.

“Transparency is not a perfect thing,”

Actually he is dead wrong on that point, he does have to disclose who he spent money on, so that also makes him a liar. The fact that he hasn’t makes him a liar who hides things. Transparency is not a perfect thing, indeed.

So, bearing those quotes in mind, one has to wonder now just exactly what the position is with the golden hand-shake of his lickspittle CEO, the guy who ran interference for Len over his expenses.

The Auditor-General has been called in to investigate lucrative golden handshakes being awarded to the chief executives of seven Auckland councils which are expected to cost ratepayers millions of dollars.

The Herald on Sunday has been told council bosses from Rodney to Franklin will receive redundancy packages with a combined cost of about $2.5 million.

The Auditor-General still hasn’t ruled on whether or not Len Brown has to tell the truth about his dinner at Volare. So I won;t be expecting any information to be forthcoming any time soon.

We do know that one council is squeaky clean though. Auckland City. We know this because Mayor John Banks does believe in transparency and transparency without limits.

Auckland City mayor John Banks has released the severance package of his chief executive David Rankin, and said there were no golden handshakes given to him by Auckland City Council. He called on other councils to do the same.

“Rankin will be paid an additional $30,000 because he has stayed on past his contractual arrangement. We didn’t want him to leave halfway through the year.

“Whereas the CEO of Manukau City has received a huge exit package, which has been kept secret as we can clearly understand it would.

“Ask Len Brown to tell you how much some of the poorest people in New Zealand have had to pay the CEO in golden handshake and golden exit packages.”

I’m pleased to see that Phil Twyford has been attempting to hold the councils to account.

Twyford had sent requests to all councils in Auckland under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act asking for the redundancy packages of executives.

Good on Phil Twyford, I suppose not having a seat to campaign for helps hugely time-wise. Though he seems a little confused as to who is responsible for holding the information, trying to pin the blame on Rodney Hide. Perhaps he should look a little closer to home politically, and ask Len Brown why he keeps secrets so much. Perhaps while he is at it he could also ask Len Brown just exactly who he was at dinner with at Volare. I mean he has been asked by LGOIMA and he refused, he is required by council rules to disclose and he refused.

I still can’t believe that Len Brown is running ads about opening the books when the books of his own council remain firmly shut to public scrutiny.

It seems we are seeing those limits that Len Brown talks about when he talks about transparency.

Now this is tough

Amongst our bravest citizens are soldiers, they willingly put themselves in harms way in order to protect us, and our way of life.

Dan Luckett though, is exceptionally tough.

Capt. Dan Luckett

When a bomb exploded under Dan Luckett’s Army Humvee in Iraq two years ago – blowing off one of his legs and part of his foot – the first thing he thought was: “That’s it. You’re done. No more Army for you.”

But two years later, the 27-year-old Norcross, Georgia, native is back on duty – a double-amputee fighting on the front lines of America’s Afghan surge in one of the most dangerous parts of this volatile country.

Luckett’s remarkable recovery can be attributed in part to dogged self-determination. But technological advances have been crucial: Artificial limbs today are so effective, some war-wounded like Luckett are not only able to do intensive sports like snow skiing, they can return to active duty as fully operational soldiers. The Pentagon says 41 American amputee veterans are now serving in combat zones worldwide.

Losing most of one foot and a leg, rehabilitating himself and then going back into combat. Wow! And not for some “in the rear with the gear” job either.

Luckett was a young platoon leader on his first tour in Iraq when an explosively formed penetrator – a bomb that hurls an armor-piercing lump of molten copper – ripped through his vehicle on a Baghdad street on Mother’s Day 2008.

His Humvee cabin instantly filled with heavy gray smoke and the smell of burning diesel and molten metal. Luckett felt an excruciating pain and a “liquid” – his blood – pouring out of his legs. He looked down and saw a shocking site: his own left foot sheered off above the ankle and his right boot a bloody mangle of flesh and dust.

Still conscious, he took deep breaths and made a deliberate effort to calm down.

A voice rang out over the radio – his squad leader checking in.

“1-6, is everybody all right?” the soldier asked, referring to Luckett’s call-sign.

“Negative,” Luckett responded. “My feet are gone.”

He was evacuated by helicopter to a Baghdad emergency room, flown to Germany, and six days after the blast, he was back in the US.

As his plane touched down at Andrew’s Air Force Base, he made a determined decision. He was going to rejoin the 101st Airborne Division any way he could.

He was and still is from one of the toughest, most active military division on earth, the the 101st Airborne Division. Rehabilitating and going back into combat with these guys was never going to be easy.

His right foot was sheered across his metatarsals, the five long bones before the toes. Doctors fitted it with a removable carbon fiber plate that runs under the foot and fills the space where toes should be with hardened foam.

His left leg was a far bigger challenge.

In early July, Luckett strapped into a harness, leaned on a set of parallel bars, and tried out his first prosthetic leg.

It felt awkward, but he was able to balance and walk.

The next day, Luckett tried the leg on crutches – and tried to walk out the door.

“They were like, ‘You gotta’ give the leg back,’” Luckett said of his therapists. After a brief argument, they grudgingly gave in. “They said, ‘If you’re gonna be that hard-headed about it, do it smart, don’t wear it all the time.’”

By February 2009, he had progressed so far, he could run a mile in eight minutes.

He rejoined his unit at Fort Campbell, Kentucky, and told his battalion commander he wanted to return to duty “only if I could be an asset, not a liability,” he recalled.

Months later, he passed a physical fitness test to attain the Expert Infantryman’s Badge. It required running 12 miles (19 kilometers) in under three hours with a 35-pound (16-kilogram) backpack. It was a crucial moment, Luckett said, “because I knew if I can get this badge, then there’s nothing they can say that I’m not capable of doing.”

The Army agreed, and promoted him to captain.

In May, he deployed to Afghanistan.

That is a remarkable achievement, of science, medicine and personal determination.

The only thing worse than being talked about….

Warning: Vanity Post, plus egregious pinko smears

Oscar Wilde said;

“The only thing worse than being talked about is not being talked about.”

And on that note enjoy;

Radio NZ’s mediawatch this morning on the impact of bloggers on the mainstream NZ media. At least they get the facts right about the Jim Anderton earthquake quote.

Radio NZ’s mediawatch this morning on the impact of bloggers on the mainstream NZ media

Denis Welch perpetrating the pinko’s lie about the source of the Jim Anderton quote. His comments are so factually incorrect as to warrant a complaint to the Broadcasting Standards Authority. Still he says “Cameron Slater” numerous times so it isn’t all bad.

The Nation’s Super City Debate – Questions on Democracy – A a regular on The Nation I got to ask about Maori representation at 8’10″ in the clip. The pinkos in the audience weren’t at all happy. :D

Len Brown’s spin weasel, Conor Roberts, said afterwards that he thought the question was a good one and worth asking. Still that’s the opinion of a paid lickspittle so probably isn’t worth a hell of a lot.

Sometimes threatening and bullying just doesn't work

from Boing Boing

In the modern age there are people who just don’t lie down when the system, or competitors or political opponents come on all the bully with you. Now, especially, you can be so more effective than hoards of over-priced lawyers by just being clever and smacking down the bully making them look like tools.

Check this video, where a small manufacturer of magnets (Zen Magnets) gets bullied by a larger company who didn’t like their comparison advertising. It is total and utter brand destruction of the big boy (Bucky Balls) in the market.

I stand with Zen Magnets, smacking bully boys in the face is always the best option.

BTW It’s a really cool toy, I’ve added this to my list of must have toys (Zen Magnets that is, not evil Bucky balls)

Labour to take action on electoral fraud

This will be fun to watch. Labour says they will take action if members are involved in the electoral fraud scam operating in Papatoetoe.

“If as a result of the police investigation into the Papatoetoe irregularities we become aware that any Party member is involved we will also take appropriate action internally.”

Nice lot of weasel words and escape plans built into that statement.

It appears that Labour will only take “appropriate” action if they become aware only via a Police investigation. For their track record on “appropriate” action we have only to look at their actions over Taito Philip Field when he was accused of corruption.

They backed him to the bitter end, and still haven’t apologised for his actions as one of their ministers and MPs after his convictions for bribery, corruption and perverting the course of justice, so far all labour has ever said about his convictions is that they acknowledge the decision of the court. Hell, they only tossed him out of the party when he made the vague hint that he might go independent. Up until that point he was “only guilty of being helpful to his constituents”.

The best bet for Daljit Singh JP is to continually say he is loyal to Labour. That way they will remain steadfast to his cause. he has good support from labour already. Efu Koka, Ross Robertson, Len Brown, top shelf Labour support.

Len Brown and Daljit Singh

Len Brown and Daljit Singh