Pay your tax then we will listen to you

Matt McCarten is whining that compulsory Kiwisaver is just an extra tax on workers, one that should be paid out of PAYE:

Raising the employers’ contribution by half a per cent each year, until it reaches 7 per cent, just means that most employers will deduct that amount from any annual wage increase offer they would normally make.

Effectively, most workers will be paying the whole lot. This is for a retirement fund that, up until now, their PAYE tax has covered.

Politicians pretending that raising the retirement age is a sacrifice we are all going to have to make are being disingenuous.

Matt knows all about PAYE, the organisations he runs simply don’t pay it. Then he has the audacity to suggest that retirement should be funded out of something he doesn’t even pay.

Maybe Matt would be a bit more believable if his organisations actually paid their PAYE. I’m surprised he even mentioned it in his column.

  • Scanner

    Why does this union enjoy such a relationship with the IRD, the rest of us that run companies (and pay our taxes) would have been wound up and in court facing fraud charges long ago.
    Regardless of our opinion of Matt the facts are he and his “company” have broken the law and should be dealt with accordingly.

  • Ghostwhowalksnz

    IRD doesnt work that way.As long as you put in your returns regularly and make some effort at paying they are  happy to rack up the penalties. 
     Not enough staff and resources to drag them into court, thats only for those who make false claims or dont make any returns. Surely you have noticed the big  cuts to IRD staffing levels in the last  12 months

  • VycyVC

    mmmnnnn. Not Paying PAYE.

    That sounds familiar

    glasshouses

    • http://www.whaleoil.co.nz Whaleoil

      Actually I did. Took me 3 years but I did it, so fuck off with your muckraking, coward.

      I didn’t go bankrupt I fronted.

      • VycyVC

        You lying hypocritical piece of shit.

        1. You paid no-one… the Liquidator did.
        2. The IRD and everyone else you owed money to only got 20c in the dollar.

        So you fuck off.

        Worthless prick

        • http://www.whaleoil.co.nz Whaleoil

          You should do better than read a liquidators report.

          IRD came after me as did a finance company, they bankrupted Paul staples, but I paid them separately, I am still paying marac for a car so take your lies elsewhere.

          You’d do better than listening to whiny cunts.