Clarkson on Suicide

Jeremy Clarkson is in hot water again. This time over his comments that people who suicide are selfish. I have always maintained that people who kill themselves are selfish, but I haven’t expressed it in the same way Clarkson has:

“I have the deepest sympathy for anyone whose life is so mangled and messed up that they believe death’s icy embrace will be better,” Clarkson said in his column in the Sun newspaper.

“However, every year around 200 people decide that the best way to go is by hurling themselves in front of a speeding train.

“In some ways they are right. This method has a 90 per cent success rate and it’s extremely quick.

“However, it is a very selfish way to go because the disruption it causes is immense. And think what it’s like for the poor train driver who sees you lying on the line and can do absolutely nothing to avoid a collision.”

Later in the article the presenter referred to those who choose to jump in front of trains as “Johnny Suicide” and argued that following a death, trains should continue on their journeys as soon as possible.

“The train cannot be removed nor the line reopened until all of the victim’s body has been recovered. And sometimes the head can be half a mile away from the feet,” Clarkson adds.

“Change the driver, pick up the big bits of what’s left of the victim, get the train moving as quickly as possible and let foxy woxy and the birds nibble away at the smaller, gooey parts that are far away or hard to find.”

Clarkson really lays down a challenge for Paul Henry with those comments.

  • Anonymous

    Ol’ Clarkson loves the hot water, ay.  “Let foxy-woxy and the birds nibble away…..”  Ewwwww….

  • kevin

    He creates quite a mental picture of such a happening…

  • Tristanb

    It’s a fair enough comment. What asshole ruins everyone else’s day by killing themselves in such a public way?

    It reminds me of that absolute piece of shit alcoholic Tony Worrell who killed that poor 26 year old newly-wed because he wanted to die. Then he lied about it.

    If you’re so far-removed from humanity that you’d harm, kill or scar innocent people, then stay home and slit your own throat.

  • Dublej

    Of course its “selfish”..as are ALL human actions. If selfish in the Randian sense then of self interest then its the individuals choice and their right to do.

  • Dublej

    I hasten to add that its not their right to involve un-consenting others in their bid of course… that’s shitty.

  • Rightry

    A bullet through the temple’s best.  Quick, clean, and others don’t have to see it happen.

    And as for Ann Rand, she should’ve been killed at birth.

    • Dublej

      With the bitch who birthed you…

  • Kosh103

    Sigh, every day Clarkson becomes more and more repugnant.

    • Super Guest

      And every day you become more and more tedious. Come on, Kosh (if that is your real name) go indulge in hyper-paranoid conspiracy theorising and workers of the world unite bullshit over at the Standard.

      • Guest

        Wow. If that’s how people who disagree with the blogger get treated, I don’t think I’ll bother commenting or indeed ready this blog any more.

  • RightoverLabour

    No, it’s selfish as the one who does it does not give a toss about those left behind to pick up the pieces or deal with the guilt. It’s just about them escaping their crisis, and stuff the world. Clarkson is not repugnant, he just says aloud what many think, but are too scared to say. 

    • Anonymous

      Here`s one for you Kosh ,and all the other namby fucking pamby fuckwits that can`t handle reality or the freedom of speech.

      http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=5dd_1322866011

      • Kosh103

        What a stupid thing to say – cant handle freedom of speech.

        That would better describe you. I have expressed what I feel inregards to Clarksons comment. Are you now going to suggest he has more of a right to say what he is thinking than I do?

    • Kosh103

      Yes he is repugnat. Using others distress to get in cheap shots and his face on the news again.

      • Anonymous

        You have just been whining about Clarkson exercising his right to freedom of speech ,you fucking cretin, on a TV show he was invited on to ,and gave an answer to a question he was asked . Get over yourself .

      • Kosh103

        @ titanuranus – wrong. I am unimpressed with what the uneducated idiot said. Not his right to say it.

        Try to understand the difference.

  • Johnboy

    Never worked out why when some fuckin incompetent wraps itself round a bridge abutment they have to close the highway for 6 hours.

    Should just bulldoze the crap into a skip bin, hose the brains and stuff off the road and let the rest of us get on our merry way ASAP.

  • workingman

    Well I have seen this from 2 sides. The son of a close friend committed suicide. It was horrendous. No one, and I repeat, no one saw it coming. Not his mother, nor his girlfriend (who he only got engaged to 2 weeks before), nor his best friend since they were tiny tots. it was horrendous, but my overriding feeling for him is selfishness. Did he really sink to such despair that he though we would all be happy he killed himself. Anyway that is probably another subject.

    I have also sat on a train from London to Birmingham that hit a suicide. I was in the first carriage after the locomotive and felt the sudden braking and then there was some red liquid streaking along the windows of the carriage. Not a lot, but enough to know what it was and just hope it was not human blood. Well it was. We then sat on the train on for nearly 6 bloody hours. We could not leave the train as it was a “death scene”. It was surreal seeing obviously bits of body being carried back on stretchers or in bins. 

    My sister is also a train driver out of London into Essex. She talks to me about suicides and the affect on the drivers. A surprisingly large percentage can never drive a train again they are so upset. So they go from quite a well paid job to a lower paid job and this of course also affects their families, all because some selfish bastard decided to throw themselves in front of a train. 

    Clarkson is spot on with this. 

  • Kthxbai

    Clarkson?  He’s such a narcisstic idiot that no-one takes any real notice of wht he says.

    • Super Guest

      Yeah, that’s why everything he says is reported ad nausea.

  • Sadu

    Clarkson is bang on for the second time in a week.

  • Thorn

    He is a pragmatist who has the courage to say what most people feel, but dare not say. Its OK to suicide but do it in a way that does not inconvenience others – frankly, you are not worth the bother and you create PTSD in otherwise useful people. This does open the argument for legal assisted death, with financial incentives perhaps.

  • Accipere

    I’m with Clarkson. All the mental health professionals tip toe around the subject of suicide, berating Clarkson as tasteless, but such suicides are  the ultimate act of selfishness for teh hurtabnd harm they inflict on others. If more people were critical of those who contemplated such a spectactularly messy end that traumatises so many others, then potential suiciders might either have cause to reconsider, or at least have the decency to choose an exit that is less frightful for others to deal with. 

  • Brian Smaller

    I am with Clarkson here too. Having seen a suicide in Australia where a guy just up and jumped in front of an express roaring through the station and bits of the guy went everywhere – including onto people who were waiting for the train. Selfish bastards indeed. Kosh – you are a dickhead. Ever seen arms and legs spread down a platform?

  • Anonymous

    Perhaps a Dummies Guide To Suicide focusing on how to do it discretely and correctly. IMHO the attention seeking suicide failures are worse that the successful applicants.

  • rustle19

    selfish no, brave yes in the most awful kind of way, enlighten yourselves and read/view anything by Thomas Joiner on suicide e.g. on youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrEAdsqLrio