Whaleoil Awards – Best Electorate MP

There were loads of nominations. This may well be the largest poll I have conducted.

According to my commenters here are who we should be considering for the Whaleoil Award for Best Electorate MP.

Sam Lotu Iiga – Nominated by a Maungakiekie resident who says:

…as a Maungakiekie resident of 34 years who has seen this electorate transform from the Labour stronghold of Onehunga held in succession by Hugh Watt, Fred Gerbich, the tosspot trougher Richard Northey & the likeable Mark Gosche. Sam took the seat out in fine style as a rank outsider in 2008 by 1900 votes and increased his margin to almost 3000 in 2011. As a bonus he helped his good mate Alfred Ngaro into the house & enabled us to rid ourselves of detested unionist Carol Beaumont.

Sam is often criticised for not performing to his utmost in order to secure promotion to ministerial ranks but the fact is that he spends far too much of his time doing what great constituency MPs do. His office door is invariably open and he lends his support regardless of race, colour or creed.

Chris Hipkins - did pretty extraordinarily well to retain Rimutaka by such a large margin despite Labour being whipped in the party vote. He worked his arse off for that electorate in the last three years. Like him or not, good on him. While supposedly experienced campaigners and high fliers like Burns, Cosgrove, Ardern, Speuloni and Little all lost winnable marginal seats, Hipkins has made Rimutaka his seat for life by being an active and appreciated local MP.

Damien O’Connor - for sticking up for himself, dropping off the list and going for it in the electorate alone. That took some balls. Most of all for calling it like it is:
“I wouldn’t trust them. Between a gaggle of gays and some self-serving unionists, I’m not sure that a straight shooter such as myself would be  given a fair deal.”

Kate Wilkinson – for exiting Clayton Cosgrove in Waimakiriri despite the constant sledging of the usual Labour nasties, notably Trevor Mallard. To unseat Cosgrove takes some doing and Kate must have convinced a great many constituents that she would represent them better than Clayton Cosgrove.

Nicky Wagner – for see ing off Lord Burns of Marlborough and working terribly hardlocally to secure the support fo the locals after a lifetime of Labour representation.

Nikki Kaye – took the seat off Labour and Judy T, then held it against Jacinda Ardern. Reportedly knocked on over 10,000 doors. Stuck up for locals on Great Barrier over mining and went against the party bosses.

Nick Smith – for making Nelson a fortress for Nick Smith.

Best Electorate MP

  • Damien O'Connor (27%, 106 Votes)
  • Sam Lotu Iiga (26%, 100 Votes)
  • Nikki Kaye (24%, 95 Votes)
  • Nicky Wagner (8%, 32 Votes)
  • Nick Smith (6%, 24 Votes)
  • Kate Wilkinson (6%, 22 Votes)
  • Chris Hipkins (3%, 10 Votes)

Total Voters: 389

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Waldo

    Hipkins?  You have to be joking.  If the local papers hadn’t given him so much free coverage and had given Mr Fletcher a fair chance, the result would have been much different.  Fletcher ran an admirable campaign, having only a few months to build a profile and standing as number 67 on the list against Chippie.  Fletcher still got almost 14,000 votes in traditional Labour heartland territory – and he was there campaigning for the party vote!  So it is hardly surprising there was a lot of vote splitting and Hipkins won the seat.  Chippie took Rimutaka for granted, and got creamed in the party vote.  Next time round, I doubt he will be so lucky – hardly a seat for life.

    • Michael

      Jonathan Fletcher was the blandest candidate of the bland National Party candidate list. If National selected a decent candidate then it would have been closer.

  • Anonymous

    A tough call. I went for Sam Lotu Iiga. The clincher for me was that he’s turned a former Labour stronghold into a National one. 

  • Anon

    I wouldn’t have voted for her, but how come Paula Bennett didn’t get chosen? She got nominated quite a few times in the previous posts comments

    • http://www.whaleoil.co.nz Whaleoil

      I couldn’t in all conscience include an MP with just 60 members.

      • Anon

        Sorry for what is most likely a dumb question, but what do you mean, an MP with just 60 members?

      • Anon

        what do you mean?

    • Peter Wilson

      I’m picking WO means the party has only 60 members in Paula’s electorate. Ergo, she’s not representing her people at all well.

      • Anon

        I see.  That really is shocking.  Does anyone know where statistics on members of parties in different electorates would be?

  • Dcrampton

    Peter Dunne should have been there. He’s been a good electorate MP since Nikki Kaye was in nappies.

    • Paul Rain

      Peter Dunne- the best reason to vote for Aoteroa Legalize Cannabis, the National Front, or the Liberterianz, cos it’s not like your vote counts anyway.

  • Guest

    Damien O’Conner, Nicky Wagner & Kate Wilkinson were list MP’s until the recent election.  

  • Guest

    Damien O’conner did absolutely nothing for West Coast -Tasman in his previous 15 years as an ELectorate MP, not sure whats going to change now. The only reason he lost in 08 was because people were sick of him, rather than auchinvole was more popular

    • Liberty

      O’conner 
      was a labour party apologist first second and third.    

      Clarks opinion of the coasters  as feral and inbred said it all.  

      Best MP award what a joke.    

  • Rwm

    Damien O’connor, the only honest MP in the Labour Party.

    • Jackhenderson00

      You don’t know the man. You would be disappointed.

  • http://truebluenz.com/ Redbaiter

    Some people are actually voting for Nick Smith???

    FFS..!!

    I thought that was a joke.

  • Super Guest

    First time in my life I’ve ever voted for a Labour candidate. 

  • Lcmortensen

    Nikki Kaye – name one other single 31-year old female who has the courage to knock on random guys’ doors and give away her phone number for free?

    • Anonymous

      You obviously don’t know the Hutt very well :D

  • Jackhenderson00

    Damien O’Connor is an inneffective apologist with some pretty despicable personal baggage. It’s a real shame Auchivole was pipped.