Another of Labour's policy ideas destroyed by facts

Labour have told us that the poor don’t have proper diets. That they need to be encouraged to eat better and that they have the solution to all of this by removing GST from fresh fruit and vegetables.

It sounds lovely, it sounds believable, but unfortunately some scientists have rained on Labour’s parade. Simple put the poor aren’t fat.

In both the popular press and academic research, there is the argument that the growth of fast food and energy-dense food has been an important cause of the overweight epidemic in the U.S. and that this has disproportionately affected poor people. [Some] argue that limited economic resources may shift dietary choices toward a diet that provides maximum calories at the least cost. An implication of this line of research is that the poor cannot afford healthy diets.

That is certainly Labour’s contention. But is it right?

Contrary to conventional wisdom, … the poor have never had a statistically significant higher prevalence of overweight status at any time in the last 35 years. Despite this empirical evidence, the view that the poor are less healthy in terms of excess accumulation of fat persists.

So it isn’t true.

Distribution-sensitive measures of overweight … [show] that the severity of overweight has been higher for the poor than the nonpoor throughout the last 35 years. … The strongest relationship between income and BMI is observed at the tails of the distribution. … For those at the tails of the BMI distribution, increases in income are correlated with healthier BMI values.

In plain english what that means is that there IS a co-relation between poverty and fat – both the very fattest and the very thinnest people tend to be poor, which then explains why we have an obesity epidemic amongst children and kids going to school hungry as well.

Quite how removing GST off fresh fruit and vegetables will solve that is another matter entirely. I’m assuming that Labour doesn’t have the answers but will employ an expert group to tell us otherwise.

 


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

Tagged:
  • Whafe

    One only need observe the shopping trolleys in a supermarket of the deemed less well off in New Zealand. It paints a grim picture.

    If Labour, or which they do believe removing GST on Fruit & Vegetables will have an effect on the less well off, for the better etc etc, their heads are further up their asses than can believed…..

    Purchasing a 10Kg bag of Potatoes, a whole cabbage, carrots, a pumpkin etc can feed a family quite economically, people seem to forget this…..

  • thor42

    Good ol’ moronic Labour. People – *any* people – will not stop eating delicious pies just because of Labour’s crazy idea.
    Social engineering. First it was lightbulbs, and now it’s this.

48%