National to win Te Atatu is underpriced

Election Results has a piece on Te Atatu which makes for interesting reading. Certainly more interesting than Bombers mad rantings at Tumeke on a similar subject.

Carter may yet decide to run as an independent or for another party and a stock on this issue is currently rating this as an 11 percent chance.

It is unlikely Carter could win the seat, but despite his reputation in some circles for arrogance he was a hard working local MP who could hurt Labour’s chances if he felt like doing so.

Carter won the seat with a majority of 5289 over National’s Tau Henare, but National in fact won a greater share of the party vote by 13,183 to 13,171.

Henare is standing again for National against Labour’s Phil Twyford, though the iPredict market does not rate his chance highly.

Henare has been working hard in the seat for some years and Twyford is a relative newcomer to the area as his hunt for an electorate to call his own finally came to an end.

Another possible wild card is a third serious candidate throwing their hand in the ring.

Te Atatu is the one of many seats Winston Peters is rumoured to be considering standing in.

If this is the case and he does stand a chance then the other candidate winning the seat stock for Te Atatu could be considered to be seriously under priced, though even if Peters does stand it would seem extremely unlikely he could take it.

One thing the article doesn’t take into account is the utter collapse of Labour’s committee and organisation structure since the controversial selection of Phil Twyford. National seems to be under-priced in Te Atatu according to all this.


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

  • giblet

    Carter is greedy enough to stand so that he gets three month salary after being defeated as a sitting MP. If he does not stand then his salary comes to a sudden halt on election day.

  • rouppe

    Why would Carter put himself under that scrutiny again? It would bring out all the nastiness of Labour against him. For what?

    He’s off to the UN anyway; better pay, better perks, less examination of what he actually does