The CBD is Dead

Sir Robert Jones is the first to spell out the issues for the Christchurch CDB in words that politicians fear to use.

It is time to face the reality that the Christchurch central business district (CBD) cannot be rebuilt.

Cities have many components, such as libraries, art galleries, council offices, theatres, halls and other public facilities. These comprise the indulgent element, paid for from the public purse. But they cannot exist in isolation and alone constitute a city. Rather, they emanate from the steady organic growth of a city’s commercial activities in the form of shops and offices.

Prior to the earthquakes, Christchurch’s CBD retail heart was already in trouble, with empty shops abounding, while those remaining lived off the office workers, now gone. This was a direct consequence of the construction of large suburban shopping centres, which killed off the CBD as a retail location, just as has occurred in many other cities throughout the Western World. Examples in New Zealand include Lower Hutt and now, increasingly, Hamilton.

It would be possible to build a new, smaller Christchurch CBD with high-rise office buildings to support a smaller retail base, if the office buildings were confined to a tight area. But while that is physically possible, it is absolutely not financially feasible for several reasons.

The CBD is not financially feasible and Sir Robert explains why:

First, because these buildings would be new they would require rentals, on my estimation, at least 400 per cent higher than the pre-earthquake price level. Because of the earthquake factor, engineering costs would be significantly greater than hitherto, as would insurance costs, and on top of that would be a risk premium. At such rates, tenants would not be forthcoming and, therefore, neither would developers.

Aside from that, the investors needed to take the end product off the developer would shy away, and without such pre-commitment, banks would not fund their construction. Pre-earthquake Christchurch was deemed a poor office-building investment location by major professional investors for sound reasons, because its office market lacked rental, and therefore capital, growth potential. Thus, the city’s buildings were owned by local hobbyists and sentimentalists, as is the case with our provincial cities.

Already, Auckland commercial real estate agents are reporting a deluge of Christchurch commercial property owners seeking to reinvest their insurance proceeds in a superior investment location. In that sense, for many of these people, the earthquake has proven to be a saviour windfall.

Very refreshing words from an old hand at investments, development and building.


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

  • thor42

    I agree with him. Given that the CBD was apparently struggling even *before* the quakes, it would be insanity to attempt to rebuild the CBD to a similar size again. Given that, that’s probably exactly why it WILL be done.

  • Stuart

    One of the better pieces I have seen, unlike the wank by Lord Burns of Marlborough to get other people to pay for the doing up of some old dunger buildings.

    Bob Jones has put his money where his mouth is saying I will not invest and for these reasons.

    Come on your Lordship Mortgage the Family Pile and put the money into old dunger buildings in Christchurch instead of just banging your gums and expecting the rest of us to pay.

  • Wally Anchor

    Bugger all people went to the CBD before the quakes unless they worked there, or felt the need to buy overpriced drinks on a Friday/Saturday night. Nobody shopped there unless they were there anyway (for work).
    Business have moved on and found new premises.
    There’s bugger all existing buildings left. Nobody that worked in a high rise want’s to go back into anything more than a couple of stories high.
    It’d be stupid to build there. Insurance would be obscenely high, and they’d be strugging to find tennants at any price.
    I certainly have no desire to go back in – except as a one-off disaster tourist.

  • Jonathan W

    With or without earthquakes, Christchurch remains the largest city in the South Island, the largest port and distribution hub, the largest center of infrastructure and IT, and the most geographically central. Whether a few high-rises in the CBD get rebuilt or not is irelevent. Any business operating throughout the South Island will need a Christchurch office, and a ground floor space in Papanui or Riccarton is as good as an 8th story office in the CBD.

    As a business and retail district the Christchurch CBD may well be dead. But the earthquakes have probably just accelerated a trend that (as you point out) already exists in other centers.

  • Scanner

    Bob Jones is right, now is the opportunity for the city to reincarnate itself into something that represents this century.
    As for saving the old buildings, most of them were, with a few exceptions, just grey old shitters, a bit like the current Labour front bench.