The answer is yes

Sydney Morning Herald

Is Labor’s brand dead?

THE rout inflicted on the ALP in Queensland was extraordinary – grim indeed for the Labor faithful, and a startling result even for experienced observers familiar with Australian political history.

Some will bracket this debacle with the defeat Labor suffered at the last NSW election, add to the mix that ALP governments were removed from office at the last state elections in Victoria and Western Australia, point to the Gillard government’s consistently low primary vote in the polls, and be tempted to conclude that Labor’s future is bleak, even that the party might be on a slippery slope to irretrievable irrelevance.

Others will contend that it’s not all over for Australia’s oldest party, partly because it is Australia’s oldest party. That is, the ALP has been around for 121 years, and has survived the most tumultuous ructions and upheavals, vicissitudes and plummets.

Moreover, just four years ago the ALP was in government in every state as well as federally. So to some extent there’s a cyclical element at play here; if you’re in government long enough, the “it’s time” factor kicks in, the punters stop listening, and the voting volatility (which has been particularly pronounced in Queensland) practically ensures your demise.

The ALP does have serious questions to ponder, as concerned activists have been emphasising for some time. To what extent does its malaise stem from the fact that the party has largely achieved the objectives that it was formed to pursue? And has struggled to shape a compelling set of contemporary aims and internal structures for the very different Australia of today? Labor has repeatedly demonstrated its resilience and adaptability in emerging from lacerating splits, demoralising defeats and philosophical tussles.


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

  • Simo

    Watch Aussie next year, the ALP will get caned out of office. The NZLP is leading the charge in the same direction. There only method of resusitation is nasty,negative and digging dirt on the Nats, no scandal no traction…..the ACC issues will past, Little and Mallard will cave in as Crusher tightens the rack. 

  • @BoJangles

    Labour career pollys are in it for ‘Glory”  They have no association with Labour’s past, not that it is relevent any more, but any hint of life experience is lacking, as is the aspirational element.

  • thor42

    I only wish Labour here were as dead as the Aussie version.
    Unfortunately, that will never be the case. Here, there will always be a critical mass of beneficiaries who will vote Labour no matter what.

  • simo

    You can thank Clarkula for the critical mass of bludgers, “it” grew the expectation and the entitlement mob, and jeeez they dont like the medicine at the moment……