More risks for the Mixed Ownership Model

by Winslow Taggart

It seems that anything that can go wrong, will go wrong for the government’s push on mixed ownership for state assets.

First, the broker community rebelled against excessive Commerce Commission interference for publicly listed companies, after ComCom draft decisions wiped hundreds of millions of dollars of NZ investment away. Senior brokers and funds managers warned that the partial floats will be at risk from investors spooked by the uncertain regulatory environment. The replacement of the tired and emotional Ross Patterson with Stephen Gale is a useful first step, but nowhere near the big shakeup the ComCom needs.

Then, the Maori Council have greedily and opportunistically raised water rights as a blatant grab on future earnings by the power companies that will be part floated. While it seems that the Maori Party have accepted assurances from PM Key, the question is, whether “Mr Market” will do likewise.

Now, the capability of the lead broker for the SOE floats is being called into question. Craigs Investment Partners has just been fined by the NZX Disciplinary Tribunal for bodgy trades by clients. Unknown software errors then compounded the error with faulty filters. This will hardly inspire the government, who is relying hugely on Craigs to lead the process successfully. If their trading system is riddled with faulty filters easily distorted by clients entering rubbish bids, then the government should demand Craig either guarantee their system or spread the load amongst other brokers like First NZ, Forsyth Barr and Hamilton Hindin Greene.

As we are reminded by the wise writings of Warren Buffett, markets are determined by fear and greed. Ominously for the government, their vaunted SOE sales programme may well be defined by a troika of fear; fear of regulation, fear of Iwi interference, and fear of broker failure.


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

  • Guest

    Craigs Investment Partners is not the lead on the SOE listings programme. They were not awarded the role months ago. I expected a much higher standard in accuracy from you Whaleoil!

  • Guest
  • Neil

    Oh dear another private sector fuck up – knew that could happen – when money for me matters more than morality…..

  • Mediaan

    Looking for who is lead adviser, to check Guest’s statement, it seems to be split up this year. There are many names involved, and the so-called Mom and Pop section is separated from the big players section as well.

    In 2011 it was in the hands of Deutsche Bank and Craig’s as to much of it.

    Better info would be welcome, but the WO statement seems fine.

    First New Zealand Capital working with Credit Suisse Australia, Macquarie Capital New Zealand, and Goldman Sachs New Zealand are the joint lead managers for this year’s MRP sale, while UBS New Zealand, Forsyth Barr working with Merrill Lynch, Deutsche Bank and Craigs Investment Partners are also available for subsequent offers.”

  • Mediaan

    Please note.
    The final paragraph of my comment above is sourced from, 29 May 2012.

  • Guest

    Deutsche and Craigs were the financial advisers to Treasury on the early stage preparatory work. Craigs is not a lead manager on the IPO itself so WO is still inaccurate.