Did Judith Collins just put her hand up for the Auckland mayoralty?

Judith Collins gives Len Brown a right kicking and outlines what is wrong in Auckland.

Auckland needs a mayor with guts. Any takers?

I’ve never had a cross word with Len Brown. In all the years I’ve known him as a lawyer, as a Manukau city councillor, as Mayor of Manukau and then Mayor of Auckland, we’ve never had any unpleasantries. Perhaps that’s his problem. He’s had a lifetime of saying “yes” when occasionally he should have said, “no”. He’s a nice, pleasant person who, unfortunately, has not delivered for the people of wider Auckland.

Perhaps we shouldn’t have listened to the royal commission that Labour set up and left us with. Perhaps we should have gone for the Three Cities option that Sir Barry Curtis and Sir Bob Harvey promoted. But, whatever, this is what we have. A sprawling city the size of London with a population the size of Perth’s.

What we desperately needed in our mayor was strength. Credibility and the ability to dominate the conversation wouldn’t have gone astray, either. The ability to bring all sides together, to inspire, to drive through vision would have been welcome. Instead, we got a Labour ex-councillor who peopled his office and his team with ex-unionists and people whose mission it was to keep him in a job no matter what. It could have been so much more.

I knew Brown was doomed when he stated that he was the second-most important person in New Zealand after the prime minister. Really? When Auckland’s mayor thinks his job is to have a foreign relations policy, you know it’s all over. Where were his advisers? Who was saying, “Earth to Len?”

Len Brown was always a third rate conveyancing lawyer in a small suburban office in South Auckland. He was never remotely qualified to lead Auckland.

And so we come now to who will replace him. I give points to Mark Thomas who doesn’t have a huge profile – which really is needed to win. At least Thomas has had the courage to say he’s standing. At least he has had the courage not to pretend and insult the voters by playing coy.

Mark Thomas has courage, I’ll give him that. He isn’t looking for a sure thing, or the next trough to find…but he is a political retard.

When I first stood for election during that terrible time (for National) of 2002, I was a lawyer. I worked in a large law firm and I was chair of the Casino Control Authority. As soon as I was selected for the then-marginal seat of Clevedon, I stood aside from both those positions. I took unpaid leave from my full-time work. That meant I really had skin in the game.

In those dark days of campaigning, when the winter election was called early, and our poll numbers dropped from over 30 per cent to just 20.7 per cent on election day, I can tell you that I had everything to win and nothing to lose. Like our Prime Minister, John Key, I had stood by challenging a sitting National MP. It was not easy. It was difficult. But it was also rewarding to come through, like the PM, and take two seats even though the party was doomed to the worst defeat it ever had.

You have to have skin in the game. Too many failed politicians want to go from free-loading off the taxpayer to free-loading off the ratepayer, without a halt in the free-loading and if they can double up on it for a term or a few months then all the better.

Auckland needs a mayor who is able to work with the Government. The mayor must be able to work with the Government to get the assistance with infrastructure that a growing Auckland needs. The mayor should be focused on solutions for infrastructure, not on world leadership in the foreign affairs stakes.

Auckland needs roads first and foremost. The Central Rail Link is a good idea and would be a lot better if it included stations at the University of Auckland and AUT. The fact that it won’t include Auckland City Hospital is a lost opportunity. But, then again, Auckland’s hills and gullies make this extremely expensive. Therein lies one of the other issues that London, for example, doesn’t face. Auckland is not flat. It’s built around 60 volcanic cones after all.

And we Aucklanders love our cars. Many Aucklanders work in south Auckland and live in west Auckland. That’s the nature of Auckland. Buses travel on roads. Rail is useful and needed but it’s not the only solution.

Auckland’s mayoralty needs, guts, determination, intelligence and presence. Who’s up for it?


From the swinging response of Phil Goff it looks like Judith Collins might have put the shits up him with the thought she might stand.


– Fairfax

Do you want:

  • Ad-free access?
  • Access to our very popular daily crossword?
  • Access to daily sudoku?
  • Access to daily code cracker?
  • Access to Incite Politics magazine articles?
  • Access to podcasts?
  • Access to political polls?

Our subscribers’ financial support is the reason why we have been able to offer our latest service; Audio blogs. 

Click Here  to support us and watch the number of services grow.