Hey Nick Smith, your concrete cancer issue isn’t going away


Yesterday building and housing minister Nick Smith ‘ordered’ MBIE to ‘look beyond mesh to other products deemed to be critical to a building’s safety’.

Regular readers may be wondering if Nick Smith was quietly hoping the Concrete Cancer Cover-Up series would go away. But as with the steel mesh issue, it’s only a matter of time before problems hidden away out of sight, bubble to the surface.

Building and Housing Minister Nick Smith has ordered the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) to look beyond mesh to other products deemed to be critical to a building’s safety.

Steel & Tube seismic mesh, and steel mesh from Eurocorp, recently failed ductility tests and were withdrawn from sale. Inquiries into steel mesh standards came after an RNZ News investigation.

Nick Smith got a canning after pretending there wasn’t a problem with dodgy high alkali cement being imported from Vietnam and thrown into the $46 million Manukau District Court rebuild.

Now we see comments from Auckland Council GM for building control Ian McCormick that:

“council regularly came across imported building products with compliance issues.”

“We’ve got products that are coming into the country which … have got endorsements on them which we are actually struggling to be able to trace and confirm are actually accurate.”

Oh really, and where did these products eventually end up? Maybe in Auckland Councillors’ ASB Tower?

In the past month revelations of Steel & Tube misusing a lab’s logo on its test certificates have snowballed into the listed company’s seismic mesh failing tests and being withdrawn.

Two Commerce Commission investigations are underway, and MBIE has started checking multi-storey buildings.

That last comment is quite a revelation. Sounds like MBIE was reading this blog early in March when problems with the performance of diaphragms in multi-storey buildings was first flagged.

If MBIE is going to bother with a ‘report on all critical building materials’, they may also like to re-check the specs of the concrete used in the Ministry of Justice’s Manuaku District Court building. One could suggest concrete is a ‘critical building material’.

“The government is looking and asking the ministry to see whether, given the issues that have developed with Steel & Tube over these mesh products, whether there should be a mandatory requirement in the standards to ensure that there is independent testing certification to ensure that they are up to grade.

Nick Smith is now asking officials how standards for materials are monitored. Such a shame that he didn’t bother looking into the concrete cancer fiasco where the ‘independent reviewer’ of the dodgy cement report was being paid for by the very company importing the cement in the first place.

It’s really no surprise that Nick Smith hasn’t been listening for now on 18 months. He’s well known for not listening.


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.