Dodgy DOC deal appealed in dodgy dam case

The Dodgy Hawkes Bay Regional Council is still trying to force their dodgy socialist dam through and Forest & Bird is back in the Court of Appeal trying to get the council and DOC to follow the law.

The Court of Appeal has heard Forest & Bird’s appeal against the High Court approval of the downgrade of conservation land for Hawke’s Bay’s $900 million Ruataniwha water storage project.

In February the High Court approved a land swap in the Ruahine Forest Park between the Department of Conservation (DoC) and the Hawke’s Bay Regional Council, to enable the dam to be built.

DoC is proposing exchanging 22 hectares of protected conservation land in Ruahine Forest Park for 170 hectares of farm land.

It would mean downgrading protected conservation land to stewardship status in order to allow it to be flooded for the dam.

How can 22 hectares of pristine conservation state possibly be swapped for 179 hectares of farmland. It’s not the same. What is the point of a conservation estate if you can just willy-nilly swap bits out to suit a dodgy council plan to build a dodgy dam.

Forest & Bird said the High Court was wrong to allow the land’s specially protected status be revoked for a commercial development.

The protected land is home to several threatened species, such as the New Zealand falcon and long-tailed bats.

Forest & Bird’s environmental solicitor Sally Gepp said until this case, it was understood that only stewardship land could be disposed of.

“To simply extend it to all specially protected areas throughout New Zealand and say that as long as you want to exchange them, that’s a good enough reason to revoke their specially protected status, is a really dangerous precedent that we would be extremely disappointed to see rolled out across the country.”

Forest & Bird has said the land swap put into question the protection of nearly one-third of the public conservation estate.

Yes it sets a bad precedent. I think Forest & Bird have  a good chance in this case, and the Council is going to have to have a re-think…again.

This will once again prove what a dodgy plan it all was in the first place.


– RadioNZ


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

  • F T Bear

    I think an extra 157 hectares coming into the conservation estate is a good outcome, the threatened species thing is a red herring. The farm land transferred will all become useless as farmland so will revert back to bush.
    The selfish self interested groups that have hijacked this thing is the most dodgy thing about it.
    It was and still is a good idea, the long term benefits to the people who live and work in hawkes bay are many. The sooner the diggers are down there the better.