Compulsory voting for New Zealand

We are voting positive #forabetternz...for National

Some may see it as flying in the face of democracy – but one analyst says compulsory voting may encourage New Zealand’s poorest people to have more of a bearing on the election.

ABC News’ election analyst Antony Green says that Australia had a 95 percent turnout at the last election as a result of the approach, with people hit with a fine if they refused to vote. New Zealand hasn’t had a voting turnout of more than 90 percent in over 35 years.

Mr Green told The Nation on Saturday morning that while compulsory voting essentially forces people to head to the ballot boxes, Australians aren’t too bothered by it – and Kiwis probably wouldn’t be if we were to take it up, either.

“I think Americans and the British would object to this greatly but in Australia, it’s sort of a shrug of the shoulders, and it’s probably for the common good – and I suspect if you did it in New Zealand, you’d get sort of the same attitude,” he says.

“I think Australians and New Zealanders are rather similar in thinking about those sorts of things in that way.”

However Mr Green says the impact it has on an election is far from just a shrug of the shoulders, as it gives power to Australia’s least powerful.
“If you look at most countries around the world, voting tends to be heavily dominated by older voters, it tends to be dominated by more well-off voters – and the voters who don’t vote under voluntary voting tend to be younger voters, tend to be those less engaged, less well-off,” he says.

“In Australia, all those people vote, and it’s an argument about compulsory voting in Australia that one of the consequences is Australia has one of the most redistributed of welfare systems – that the welfare we do spend is heavily directed to those who are most likely to need it.

“And one of the reasons why that’s viewed that way, is [that] under our system, all those people will vote.”

The gut feel is that forcing the disinterested to engage in the process will improve the outcome.  A gut feel is that the poor and the disconnected will trend towards the left, yet the previous Labour government  never considered compulsory voting, choosing instead to toy with prisoners voting and lowering the voting age instead.  Then it went looking for the “missing million”.

The reason there is no compulsory voting is because the party that introduces it fears a backlash from those who don’t appreciate being forced into it.  And in the end, for many, not voting is a choice they make, rather than something they might do if they were only better informed, motivated or assisted.

Better the Devil you know, and all that.

If compulsory voting were to come to New Zealand, it would probably be part of a total constitutional review such as embracing republicanism.  Until then, yeah nah.

 

– Newshub


Do you want:

  • Ad-free access?
  • Access to our very popular daily crossword?
  • Access to daily sudoku?
  • Access to Incite Politics magazine articles?
  • Access to podcasts?
  • Access to political polls?

Our subscribers’ financial support is the reason why we have been able to offer our latest service; Audio blogs. 

Click Here  to support us and watch the number of services grow.

29%