Kids doing adult Crimes should face adult consequences

New Children’s Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft has launched a campaign to persuade Cabinet ministers to raise the upper age limit for the Youth Court from 17 to 18.

Becroft, who has just started a short two-year term as commissioner after 15 years heading the Youth Court, has written to all ministers and plans to meet with all of them to get the age raised.

The Government has already introduced a bill to implement an expert panel’s proposal to raise the age limit for state care of young people in need of care and protection from 17 to 18, but ministers are believed to be divided over whether to raise the age limit for youth justice.

Helen Clark’s Labour Government introduced a bill to raise the age for leaving both state care and youth justice to 18 in 2008 but the bill was dropped by John Key’s incoming National Government at the end of that year.

Justice Minister Amy Adams said last year that she had asked officials to look again at the issue, but her predecessor Judith Collins – now back in Cabinet as Police and Corrections Minister – was firmly against it.

Is there really a point to treating a 16 year older killer or a 14 year old rapist as a child? 

Judge Becroft said it would be “illogical” to let young people stay in state care until they turned 18 while pushing them out of the youth justice system at 17, because 70 per cent of young offenders had been in the care and protection system.

Our society is full of these inconsistencies.  Kids can be parents and join the army or even the police before they are allowed to walk into a bar and order a beer.

“So we would be having in the adult District Court people who are still only children in the care and protection system. It’s going to be a complete organisational shambles,” he said.

He said there was a misperception that the youth justice system was “soft”.

And why would that be?   Why are there bands of teens marauding shops and dairies?  It is because they know that if they are considered children, they will not face the same consequences as adults.

“We have a person who is 14 who committed two serious rapes in Porirua and was sentenced to six and a half years in adult prison,” he said. “We are transferring 20 or 30 young people a year to the adult court.”But he said the youth justice system recognised that young people’s brains were not yet fully developed, and tried to steer them on to a better path to keep them out of the criminal justice system.

Society doesn’t have a problem with the system guiding teens away from petty theft.  But by the time they are part of the crew that does dozens of burglaries because  they know they’ll just get some airy fairy lovey dovey “rehabilitation” from the state, they are taking the mickey.

The solution is to declare certain crimes to be “adult” crimes, no matter what age a person is when they do it.  Aggravated assault, burglary, rape and murder would start such a list.


– Simon Collins, NZ Herald


Do you want:

  • Ad-free access?
  • Access to our very popular daily crossword?
  • Access to daily sudoku?
  • Access to Incite Politics magazine articles?
  • Access to podcasts?
  • Access to political polls?

Our subscribers’ financial support is the reason why we have been able to offer our latest service; Audio blogs. 

Click Here  to support us and watch the number of services grow.