Losing Maori support too high a price for Key, but he remains staunch

A year ago the Prime Minister used a trip to New York to announce that 620,000sq km of sea around the islands would be closed forever to fishing and ocean-floor mining.

The United Nations General Assembly learned about the sanctuary plan before New Zealand was told, and even before John Key informed his own caucus.

This failure to consult is one element in the row engulfing the conservation project, and is of the Government’s own making. It has emerged that Hollywood film-maker and Titanic director James Cameron, US Secretary of State John Kerry and an American environmental lobby all encouraged the sanctuary plan, which has fostered a view that ministers bowed to foreign pressure to create the vast protected area. Whatever the case, the political management of what was meant to be a conservation showstopper has been mediocre.

The dispute with the Maori Party is more fundamental. Under legislation creating the sanctuary, fishing rights and compensation were ruled out. The Cabinet concluded that while Te Ohu Kaimoana, the Maori fisheries commission, held fishing rights under the 1992 fisheries settlement, it was not entitled to compensation because tribes did not take fish from the Kermadecs.

Maori take the view that the 1992 agreement, known as the Sealord deal, confirmed a property right. This was how the settlement was framed at the time, and why it had the support of all tribes as it was seen as full and final. Te Ohu filed claims in court as long ago as March arguing the sanctuary extinguished the property right and emerged without consultation.

The Maori Party has moved in behind Te Ohu, forcing the Government to put the legislation on hold while it searches for a political solution. Maori Party co-leader Te Ururoa Flavell, while stopping short of saying the dispute was a coalition breaker, declared that the sanctuary’s impact on Treaty rights was “very serious”.

The last-minute stumbles suggest that the hoped-for November declaration of the sanctuary will pass without the status of the ocean changing. There are suggestions that a compromise could be hammered out, with the legislation preserving fishing rights and affected iwi voluntarily agreeing not to fish within the sanctuary area for a set time.

Iwi argue that other Pacific sanctuaries allow for sustainable fishing, but Environment Minister Nick Smith says the Government is reluctant to make an exception and undermine the very idea of a protected area.

The Government would not be in this pickle if it had engaged with Te Ohu, its support partner the Maori Party, and even commercial fishing interests from the outset. Hubris is a quality which politicians embrace at their peril.

Next year, a percent here and a percent there will make a huge difference.  National can not afford to put Maori off-side while a clearly hostile group of Maori are making a big play for power.

In the past, National has backed out quickly when it found itself in trouble.  But as we’ve seen with the Flag Referendum, that only works if it is a subordinate minister’s reputation on the line.  When it comes to John Key himself, I’ll do – or die – by his position.

At an absolute minimum, they need to manage this issue away so it becomes a decision to be made after the next elections.  The heat needs to come out of it and Maori given the idea they have all but won.

Even though the sanctuary is a good idea, it is bad politics.  Once again Key chooses to die in a ditch over something that doesn’t matter.


– NZ Herald


THANK YOU for being a subscriber. Because of you Whaleoil is going from strength to strength. It is a little known fact that Whaleoil subscribers are better in bed, good looking and highly intelligent. Sometimes all at once! Please Click Here Now to subscribe to an ad-free Whaleoil.

  • Boondecker

    Good points but frankly I feel a hint that Key is playing an election card here with the Kermadecs. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s quite willing to play some early ball with the electorate. So, yes, I would not be at all surprised if this indeed a very “do or die” moment.

    Here is my simplistic hypothesis… if the Maori Party walk away from the coalition now and at this point, I believe Key will call for an early election based on the fact the National-led government are unable to govern properly. He then relies on the Maori Party being the relatively loose and disorganised group they are stuck fighting out their seats with the likes of Labour. Key and the Nats don’t need the seemingly endless grief that comes with upset and demanding Maori MPs. Key in the mean time sows up ‘that deal’ everyone is guessing at with Winston and, hey presto, we have a new National NZ First coalition government but with Maori voters left with no more representation in government unless invited but only as an option.

    Tear it apart – it’s just my thoughts anyway.

    • Sailor Sam

      And he will have 3 more years as PM also.
      Wit McCully retiring, Winston would be a shoe in Foreign Minister.

      • Kapow!

        As much as I detest Winnie, he would be better than McCully

    • cows4me

      Yes but you might be swapping a taniwha for a cheeky darky.

    • Phoenician

      It could mean good bye to the Maori seats….

    • sandalwood789

      I think you’re spot-on, B.

      It’s about time that someone told the Maori Party to take their tikis and taniwha and “hit the road, Jack”. They seem to value fish from the Kermadecs higher than their children. That says it all for me. The sooner they’re on the Opposition benches, the better.

    • Backdoor

      Actually I think you are right on the money with that comment. Key needs an excuse to go for an early election before the Roskill by-election and before the People’s Party get the opportunity to gain traction. With Labour broke and in disarray Key is in the position to win enough seats to form a government with Winston.

      If the Kermadec issue was the cause of the early call, then it is possible Maori would back the Maori Party thus reducing Labour’s number of MPs.

      I watch this space with interest.

    • TheRobberDog

      The biggest benefit to JK going with Winnie is the ability to get some stuff done and say ‘Winnie made me do it… honest…’