Rodney Hide on pandering to race-based lobbyists

Rodney Hide explains why race-based political parties are dangerous.

The People’s Party was announced this week with a narrower focus than its name suggests. Its target is Asian and ethnic voters and its issue is fighting crime.

Prime Minister John Key pooh-poohed the party’s chances and Winston Peters attacked another race-based party as divisive.

But our political discourse is increasingly about diversity and formal and informal quotas to achieve predetermined results. The call for diversity increasingly trumps the principle “one person, one vote”.

We have reserved seats in Parliament for Maori. So why not reserved seats for other groups? Once the principle of “one person, one vote” is given away it’s impossible to draw a sensible line.

My experience is with setting up the new Auckland Council. We almost had reserved council seats for Maori and as a consolation, the Maori Party pushed for a Maori Statutory Board. That left then Minister of Ethnic Affairs Pansy Wong aggrieved and so an Ethnic People’s Advisory Panel was ordered.

It had to be a panel not a board because ethnic groups were deemed less worthy than Maori because they came later and hadn’t signed the Treaty. I kid you not.

Of course, that was but the start.   

Once the council got going it felt Parliament hadn’t gone far enough and, to achieve more diversity, established a Senior’s Advisory Panel, a Pacific People’s Advisory Panel, a Youth Advisory Panel, a Disability Advisory Panel and Rainbow Communities Advisory Panel.

It would seem in the panel hierarchy the Rainbow Communities and Pacific People’s are of lesser significance than Ethnic Peoples because they don’t enjoy statutory protection.

That’s the nuttiness of dividing the body politic into groups of collective interest rather than staying with the principle of “one person, one vote” all voting in the same pool to achieve the “general good”.

Once the carve-up starts, there’s no logical end to it.

The People’s Party should not be disheartened. On present trends the parties will reserve places on their lists for the various groups and Parliament could well establish quota to ensure diversity.

You can’t have too much of a good thing.

I believe the People’s party will fail, or attract such and assortment of ratbags who will quickly be exposed it will fail from its own “success”.

By creating special classes of people we are very quickly alienating many other voters. I wonder how long before there will actually be a party formed called the Sensible party that will dispense with all this nonsense and actually do sensible things…like ban banning, or prevent horse floats, trailers, and caravans from travelling the highways during daylight hours.


– Herald on Sunday

Do you want:

  • Ad-free access?
  • Access to our very popular daily crossword?
  • Access to daily sudoku?
  • Access to Incite Politics magazine articles?
  • Access to podcasts?
  • Access to political polls?

Our subscribers’ financial support is the reason why we have been able to offer our latest service; Audio blogs. 

Click Here  to support us and watch the number of services grow.