Greens nothing more than Labour’s political retarded cousin

Barry Soper observes

It was a year ago today that the Labour leadership stepped up to the podium with the Greens to mark the bond they’d formed to change the Government this year.

They did something that would have sent a shiver up Helen Clark’s spine, embracing the Greens, saying after the election if they get to form a Government everything will be up for grabs, except for one job, finance, that would go to the man who came within a hair’s breadth of beating Andrew Little to the leadership, Grant Robertson.

That was to appease those who cringe at the idea of the Greens pulling the economic purse strings.

But of course, finance would be there for Winston Peters’ taking if he wanted his old job back.

The Green party will never get near the treasury benches.  Nor any other benches.  

As a first anniversary gift, the Greens breached their Memorandum of Understanding on Budget day by voting with the Government it has pledged to replace.

Little told us he only knew they were crossing sides, when they started voting.

So much for the no-surprise policy then.

The MoU commits both parties to treat each other with integrity and openness with a no surprises policy which means they give each other prior notice and the details of any major announcements and speeches.

The last clause in their agreement agrees they can have their differences but it acknowledges they have a responsibility to discuss their position with each other before public debate.

So it’s a pretty obvious breach but the agreement’s unlikely to be worth the paper it’s written on with the Greens again facing the prospect of not even being the bridesmaid and certainly not the bride.

Did anyone believe it?  I didn’t.  My readers didn’t.  And the media never did either.

The deal with Labour is the Greens’ biggest mistake.

They may think their association could attract some Labour votes for them which, but if that’s their thinking, they misunderstand the tribal nature of that party’s followers.

If they were free agents they could easily have hooked up with National, which given their Budget vote, they don’t loathe as much as Labour does.

Certainly National’s been chortling at the suggestion but in reality knows it’s too late for that to happen, given the commitment the Greens have publicly made to get rid of them.

Just think, without the MoU, the Greens could have relegated Peters to the outside looking in, rather than quite possibly the other way round.

For that they would have to have been a true Green party.  Not a socialist party covered in wilted cabbage leaves.


– Barry Soper, Newstalk ZB

Do you want:

  • Ad-free access?
  • Access to our very popular daily crossword?
  • Access to daily sudoku?
  • Access to Incite Politics magazine articles?
  • Access to podcasts?
  • Access to political polls?

Our subscribers’ financial support is the reason why we have been able to offer our latest service; Audio blogs. 

Click Here  to support us and watch the number of services grow.