A good rebuttal of Labour’s 1970s union friendly policies

The unions bought and paid for leader, Andrew Little, delivered up a back to the future industrial relations policy which promises nationwide school holiday strikes.

People aren’t happy and are pointing out the deliberate lies and falsehoods claimed by Labour.

Labour’s industrial relations policy would return New Zealand to the dark ages of employment law, Otago-Southland Employers Association chief executive Virginia Nicholls said yesterday.

The policies announced by Labour leader Andrew Little were all called “fair”.

However, just because something was called ‘‘fair’’ did not mean it was, she said.

“It is not fair to remove opportunity or flexibility from employees and employers. I am disappointed with Labour’s industrial relations policy. It feels like we are going back to the dark ages.”

The school holidays are coming up, imagine and Air New Zealand strike or a Cook Strait ferry strike like the bad old days.

Mr Little said Labour would implement sensible changes to employment law to prevent the small number of bad employers undercutting good employers and driving a “race to the bottom” on wages and conditions.

Labour would boost the minimum wage to $16.50 an hour and base future increases on the real cost of living for people on low incomes.

Over time, Labour would work towards lifting the minium wage to two-thirds of the average wage, as economic conditions allowed.

Most employers used trial periods fairly but Mr Little said National’s “fire at will law” encouraged abuse by a small number of employers.

Labour would replace National’s law with trial periods, including protection against unfair dismissal and fast, fair, simple dispute resolution.

Labour would work with businesses and unions to implement fair pay agreements across industries, he said.

“These will stop bad employers from undermining wages and working conditions to undercut good employers.

“Fair pay agreements will lay out the basic pay and working conditions in an industry and prevent a race to the bottom.”

Mrs Nicholls said the major point here was the proposed introduction of  industry-wide bargaining through the fair pay agreements.

It would be a huge change from the enterprise-level bargaining used now.

Industry-wide bargaining, or national awards, was an old-fashioned approach to employment relations, she said. It made it harder for companies to get ahead and allowed industry-wide strikes.

New Zealand decided against industry-wide bargaining because it facilitated all the big strikes in the 1970s and 1980s that critically damaged the economy, she said.

Almost brought the economy to its knees. We had the Mangere Bridge strike and the BNZ building strike as some of the longest and most pointless strikes we’ve known. It wasn’t until the Bolger government broke the union stranglehold that New Zealand could advance.

“Business and workers have more opportunity to improve productivity and earn more under our current system.”

France and Germany  had industry-wide bargaining and wanted to get rid of it, as it was slowing down their economies, Mrs Nicholls said. They wanted to move towards the enterprise-level bargaining used in New Zealand.

Mrs Nicholls also took issue with Labour’s comments on trial periods, which she said were to help people into employment who otherwise might find it hard to get a job.

Employers found it hard to take a chance on someone without a good employment record if there was a chance of an expensive employment dispute if the new hire did not work out.

Trial periods removed that risk, giving more opportunity for people to get into work.

“Putting unjustified dismissal provisions into trial periods will increase bureaucratic processes and reduce opportunities for jobseekers.”

The left-wing are ecstatic. If they think that voters want a return to the policies of the past then why isn’t union membership growing? People vote with their wallets and when union membership became voluntary that was the end of mass unionism in NZ.



Do you want:

  • Ad-free access?
  • Access to our very popular daily crossword?
  • Access to daily sudoku?
  • Access to Incite Politics magazine articles?
  • Access to podcasts?
  • Access to political polls?

Our subscribers’ financial support is the reason why we have been able to offer our latest service; Audio blogs. 

Click Here  to support us and watch the number of services grow.