Stephen Mills

Labour’s institutional dysfunction

Danyl McLauchlan is one of the few on the left wing that I can respect.

His observations when he isn’t being silly or writing bad satire are usually spot on.

He has taken the time to discuss the Labour party and what he sees as?their impending collapse.

I don?t know if Labour is a dying party. Looks like to to me, but there?s still time to turn things around. I do think there?s an important difference between National in 2002 and the Labour Party in 2014. After their 2002 election loss National realised that it faced an existential crisis?and took drastic action. They bought Steven Joyce in to review the party, underwent a huge reorganisation and then united behind their subsequent leaders, Brash and Key. The sense?I get from Labour is that they don?t have anything to worry about because hey, National was in big trouble a few years ago and now look at them go! Sure, Labour aren?t?doing great right now but it?s just history; it?s political cycles. You gotta?ride it out and wait until the tide washes you back into government again. There was a nice example of this from former Labour President Mike Williams on the Nine to Noon political segment last week. Williams announced that the leader of the Labour leadership contest will probably be the Prime Minister in 2017 because four term governments are?rare. Forget all that hard work of somehow beating John Key, which Labour has no idea how to do, or even reforming the party. Fate will just return them to power, somehow, because that?s what sometimes happened in the past.

I don?t think Key and National see themselves as being circumscribed by fate, and that they should just resign themselves to losing in 2017. I think they?ve built a fearsome political behemoth that dominates New Zealand?s political landscape and which they hope will endure?for?a long, long time, even after Key finally retires in his fifth term (or whenever). ?Labour dying is not a worst-case scenario for the New Zealand left. Labour hanging around, slowly dwindling, occupying the political space of the center-left but not winning an election for another twenty years is the real and highly plausible doomsday scenario. I don?t know how much of National?s strength is an accident of Labour?s current weakness, but I do know that the new Labour leaders job will be reforming their party, and not beating Key. That?s not even an option for Labour until they somehow transform themselves?into a modern professional political party, and figure out who they are and what they stand for.

Read more »

Will John Key sell out Mark Mitchell in Rodney?

Stephen Mills opinion piece on stuff talking about the combinations of parties and options that will keep John Key in power after 2014.

John Key played the integrity card by ruling out New Zealand First as a coalition partner in 2008, but now he faces the unpleasant choices of courting New Zealand First and/or undertaking high-risk and possibly futile electorate plays in Epsom or Rodney – or a combination of all three.

John Key is making the same kind of noises Helen Clark did in her second term about wanting to stay at all costs. Clark stole $800,000 of tax payers money to spend in the last crucial week of the election campaign, and did a dodgy deal with Winston.? Read more »

×